Using our earlier results on polynomiality properties of plethystic logarithms of generating series of certain type, we show that Schiffmann’s formulas for various counts of Higgs bundles over finite fields can be reduced to much simpler formulas conjectured by Mozgovoy. In particular, our result implies the conjecture of Hausel and Rodriguez-Villegas on the Poincaré polynomials of twisted character varieties and the conjecture of Hausel and Thaddeus on independence of E-polynomials on the degree.